Of course lot of this is subjective, but I think this is probably Akko's best keycap set. The colors look so amazing & most accurate to the photos on this page compared to their other colorways on other keycap sets. If you love turquoise, teal, & mint color combo, then this set is definitely for you. I have not & will not bother trying the Cherry profile set, ASA is way more fun to type on than standard Cherry so I can't really say if the colors are the same exact on the Cherry profile set. Once these keycaps wear out, I will gladly buy them again, they're genuinely that good & as far as keycaps go, relatively cheap.
FYI I have also bought the Retro Carbon & Neon ASA keycap sets and this Macaw set by far looks the most accurate to their photos/renders online (assuming you have some natural lighting).
One minor downside is that the modifiers are not perfectly evenly flat. This is most relevant for the Spacebar, but also on Enter & Left Shift keycap which causes a slight wobble. This can be fixed by soaking them in some hot water & then evening them out, so not a huge deal. I have yet to do this myself, I hope the colors don't get washed out by doing this.